I am $120K deep in student loan debt and I went to a ‘best value’ university

If she had made $4,000 less that year, I’d have qualified to go to college for free.

That’s what the financial aid representative from The College of New Jersey told my mother over the phone. The income cutoff for the college’s work-study program, the Educational Opportunity Fund, was just $4,000 less than her salary. It was June 2013, two months before I’d begin my freshman year there.

“Can I just pay you $4,000 then?” my mom asked. She didn’t have that kind of money but said she could sell things or ask extended family members for help. In the world of financial aid, though, it doesn’t work that way. There has to be a line drawn somewhere, and I was just over the line.

I wasn’t worried. I knew I’d get a substantial sum of financial aid. After all, I had been a straight-A student my entire life. My parents were divorced and I lived with my mother and brother in a small apartment, where I had shared bunk beds and a bedroom with my mom for nearly 10 years.

My family couldn’t afford to buy me a car — we couldn’t even afford the cost of car insurance for me, so I couldn’t drive anyone else’s car. We didn’t have iPhones or any of the latest electronics. We didn’t have money to go on vacation, let alone out to dinner.

It had been tough to grow up in a wealthy town without so many of the luxuries that the students around me so freely enjoyed.

I got the email a few weeks later that notified me of my financial aid award from The College of New Jersey. It comprised one Federal PELL Grant worth $4,422 and the NJ Tuition Aid Grant worth $1,995. In total, I received $6,417. That means the additional $23,350 I owed needed to be taken out in student loans.

Ultimately, I wasn’t wealthy enough to afford college on my own, but not poor enough by the government’s standards to get the help I needed.

When I applied to The College of New Jersey, I didn’t understand how much debt I’d eventually be saddled with. (Sydney Shaw)

I was devastated. I was a great student in a low-income, single-parent household. I was sure I’d get more help. But I desperately wanted to go to college, so I was willing to take on the burden of student loan debt.

Then came the hunt for a cosigner.

With one parent still financially recovering from a bankruptcy, the other deep in credit card debt and one pair of grandparents taking out loans themselves to move across the country, they weren’t solid candidates to cosign for my student loans.

Stephanie, a representative from education funding provider Sallie Mae who did not wish to have her full name disclosed, answered some questions I had about the likelihood of a student to be approved for a loan, sans a cosigner.

“While it is a case-by-case basis,” she said, “in my experience, most students applying for a loan will need a cosigner in order to get that loan approved.”

Stephanie went on to explain that because most students haven’t established a good credit score, Sallie Mae has nothing to base the approval on if the student submits a solo application. That’s why a cosigner is so important. But what if you don’t have a cosigner?

“Well … try to get one,” Stephanie said.

It was a stressful summer trying to figure it out, but luckily, my other grandparents received credit approval and I was able to take out loans in my own name to attend The College of New Jersey. I thought about other students like me — those who were just over the line — who didn’t have anyone that could cosign for them. I wondered what happens to them.

This arduous process of applying for student loans is something I would have to repeat three more times during my college career.

All the money I had made from the jobs I worked in high school — as a barista, a cashier, a tutor, a medical secretary and a babysitter — didn’t even cover the cost of all of my books for my first year.

Between classes, I worked as a clerk in the College’s Office of Admissions. I worked at the College’s student-run newspaper every semester, eventually rising to serve as editor-in-chief. I completed three paid, full-time internships each summer and freelanced during that entire time. I overloaded my class schedule and took extra credits one year so I had more time to work the following year. I opened a print shop on my website and started selling my original photos and artwork.

Still, I could barely afford the cost of books each semester.

Older family members couldn’t seem to understand why I was having such a hard time. They pointed to themselves as examples of folks who had paid their own way through school, who worked full-time while somehow simultaneously attending school full-time and graduating without owing a penny.

Even if their stories are true, the world today is not the one in which they grew up. According to the Department of Education, the average price to attend a four-year college in 1980 was $9,438. In 2015, that number was $23,872. That’s nearly three times as expensive, and even more so if one considers that the average person’s income has not increased as steeply.

Today, I owe Sallie Mae $86,561. I owe the federal government $32,927. That total — $119,488 — grows each month with interest. It’s a debt I don’t see myself ever being able to repay.

Sallie Mae set my minimum payment at $1,080 each month — and that number is after they adjusted for my income and other bills. My federal student loans cost another $202 per month. My options for deferment and forbearance are already up, just a year and three months after graduation.

So now I must pay $1,282 each month toward my student loans. It’s more expensive than my friends’ rent. It’s an entire paycheck down the drain. Once I pay all my bills each month, I’m left with about $200.

God forbid my car breaks down or I have to go to the doctor.

When I don’t have enough money in my bank account to make my minimum payment, my loans go into default. The unrelenting phone calls and emails begin. It’s stressful and embarrassing.

My story isn’t unique. It mirrors those of countless students in the U.S. who willingly throw themselves into crushing debt just to earn a college degree, something that’s necessary in order to work most high-paying jobs in this country.

On August 27, 2018, a top federal official in charge of handling complaints about student loans stepped down. He blasted the Trump administration for protecting predatory lenders at the expense of borrowers like me.

Is it disappointing to think that my struggles with America’s student loan system might just be beginning? Of course.

But is it surprising?

After all the hurdles I’ve jumped to get this far, not in the slightest.

1 thought on “I am $120K deep in student loan debt and I went to a ‘best value’ university”

  1. I feel your pain.I became disabled shortly after leaving school and finding work. I had gotten married had two children one a disabled child got divorced their his father is a dead beat dad. I was hurt, poor and broke It didn’t matter. I would fill out the forms or disability deferment have my doctor sign them and they would always say something was wrong No matter how carefully the forms were filled out.or they would lose them and this went on for years as my disability got worse and i became less mobile I had to take them to an attorney before I finally got my disability approved. -16 years. They snatched my IRS check in the interim and never applied it in the print out of what was owned. Thank God that nightmare is done. I didn’t owe a tenth of what you do and the calls and paperwork was relentless I will keep you and your family in my prayers


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s